Best Fishing Kayaks: Pelican, Old Town, and Perception Compared for Anglers
Kayak fishing has exploded in popularity for good reason — a fishing kayak puts you in places a powerboat can't reach, it's cheap to own and maintain, and it slows you down in ways that make you a better angler. The market is now flooded with options at every price point. Here's what actually matters when buying a fishing kayak and how the leading models compare.
Some links in our gear reviews may be affiliate links — we always disclose when they are. We never accept payment for favorable coverage. If something isn't worth your money, we'll say so.
Old Town Topwater 106
Best mid-range fishing kayakThe Topwater 106 is the sweet spot between price and features for kayak anglers who plan to fish regularly. It's stable enough for beginner anglers to feel confident, capable enough for experienced paddlers fishing demanding water. Old Town has been making quality kayaks for over 100 years — you're buying into that reliability.
Pelican Catch 110 HDII
Best budget fishing kayakIf your budget is under $700 and you want a capable fishing kayak, the Pelican Catch 110 is the answer. It won't match premium kayaks on stability or features, but for calm lakes and sheltered coastal fishing, it performs well above its price point. Many serious kayak anglers started on a Pelican before upgrading. Consider a third-party aftermarket seat ($50–100) to improve comfort.
Perception Pescador Pro 12
Solid mid-range option, great seatThe Pescador Pro earns its place primarily on seat comfort — it genuinely has one of the best stock seats in the sub-$1000 category. If you plan to fish 6+ hour sessions, that matters. It's a quality kayak, but for fishing-specific features and long-term brand reliability, the Old Town Topwater edges it out.
Buying Guide
**Sit-In vs. Sit-On-Top**
For fishing, almost always choose a sit-on-top (SOT) kayak. You can move around more freely, gear is more accessible, and if you flip — you can remount from the water. Sit-in kayaks are harder to reenter after a capsize. All three kayaks reviewed here are sit-on-top.
**Hull Width and Stability**
Wider = more stable = more suitable for standing and casting. The trade-off is speed and paddling efficiency. For fishing kayaks where you're covering short distances and prioritizing fishing over paddling performance, width matters. Look for hulls over 30 inches wide for stable standing platforms.
**Weight Capacity and What You're Carrying**
Include your own weight plus gear. A 250 lb angler + 30 lbs of gear needs a kayak with 350+ lb capacity minimum. Overloading reduces stability significantly. All three kayaks here are rated for 350–400 lbs.
**Storage and Rigging**
Fishing kayaks should have: at minimum two rod holders (flush mount and adjustable), a front hatch or storage tank well, and a way to add accessories (mounting tracks for additional rod holders, fish finders, etc.). Old Town Topwater comes most rigged out of the box; the Pelican can be rigged up with aftermarket accessories.
**New vs. Used**
Used kayaks hold value well and depreciate slowly — a 3-year-old kayak in good condition typically costs 40–50% of new. Check for UV damage (faded/chalky hull indicates degradation), cracks near handles and hatches, and seat condition. Buying used is excellent value for budget-conscious anglers.
Launch spots, tides, and conditions for kayak anglers in the Northeast — subscribe to the weekly Hooked Fisherman update.
Sign Up — Free