Best Lures for Bluefish 2024: Metals, Poppers, and Topwater That Survive the Bite
Bluefish are tackle destroyers. Their razor-sharp teeth cut through mono leader, mangle soft plastics, and bend weak hooks. The lures that work best for bluefish are built to take abuse — metal construction, strong hooks, and minimal soft components. Here's what survives and catches blues consistently.
Some links in our gear reviews may be affiliate links — we always disclose when they are. We never accept payment for favorable coverage. If something isn't worth your money, we'll say so.
Acme Kastmaster Spoon
All-metal construction with ultra-sharp treble hook. Dense body casts a mile, sinks fast, and provides exceptional flutter action on the fall. Blues chew metal but can't destroy it. The most reliable bluefish lure at any price.Silver and blue/silver are the most productive colors. The 3/4 to 1.5 oz sizes cover most CT bluefish applications. Carry a dozen — you will lose them.
Gibbs Polaris Popper
Classic wooden surface popper with through-wire construction. Strong enough to withstand bluefish without shattering. The surface explosion of a bluefish hit on a popper is one of saltwater fishing's great moments.The Gibbs Polaris is hand-crafted in Rhode Island. The through-wire construction means a fish can chew the body and the lure still functions with the wire intact.
Point Jude Popa-Do
Small, dense metal popper that casts well on light gear and creates a spray similar to a larger popper. Excellent for albies and bluefish simultaneously. All-metal body is indestructible.The Popa-Do is a favorite of CT surf anglers targeting albies and bluefish simultaneously. Silver and blue are the standard colors.
Buying Guide
Bluefish Lure Buying Guide
Leader requirement: Use wire leader with bluefish. 12-18 inches of single-strand or 7-strand wire (American Fishing Wire size 3-5) eliminates cutoffs. Some anglers use heavy 40-50 lb fluorocarbon and accept occasional cuts — viable for non-blitz fishing.
Metal vs. soft plastic: Bluefish destroy soft plastics instantly. For a school of large choppers, all-metal lures are the only practical option. When fish are smaller (snapper blues), soft plastics work fine.
Hook upgrades: Most bluefish lures come with average hooks. Upgrade to VMC or Gamakatsu trebles in the same size for better sharpness and hook-up ratio. Bluefish hit hard and fast — a sharp hook sticks on the initial grab.
Topwater vs. subsurface: On blitzing fish, topwater creates the most exciting strikes. In lower light (dawn/dusk) and when fish are below the surface, metal lures retrieved just under the surface are more effective.
Losing lures: Bluefish sometimes clip the lure off below the wire. Accept this. Carry 6-10 lures for a bluefish session and don't use anything you'd regret losing.
Retrieve speed: Blues are speed predators. A slow retrieve rarely triggers strikes. High-speed steady retrieve, burning the lure across the surface or through the water column, is the standard approach.
Blues, stripers, fluke, and albies — complete saltwater lure reviews for Long Island Sound. Subscribe to Hooked Fisherman.
Sign Up — Free