Bluefish and Albies Turn On as Fluke Season Closes at the Shore
New Jersey's fluke season closes today, September 25, and the fall lineup already looks ready to fill the gap. Fishermans HQ LBI's surf report from mid-September still noted unusually warm water, 75°F on the Ship Bottom beach, with bonito and false albacore feeding on jigs before anglers switched over to live peanut bunker. Bluefish are the clearest story on the boards: Surf City Bait and Tackle, reporting via The Fisherman — Central NJ, calls the metal bite a sure sign the fall run is heating up, while Boulevard Bait and Tackle, One Stop Bait and Tackle, and Riptide Bait and Tackle each report tailor-to-chopper blues from 1 to 3 pounds hitting mullet, bunker chunks, and cut bait in the surf from Sea Isle to Brigantine. Stripers are stirring too. Jingles Bait and Tackle logged the LBI Surf Fishing Classic's first striper weigh-in of the season at 8.15 pounds, and Pier 47 Marina says stripers are already feeding heavily at night on paddletails and Mag Darters around the lighted docks in the Wildwoods, with the higher tides producing the better catches. Tautog have moved onto structure as well, with One Stop Bait and Tackle noting blackfish feeding hard on crab baits, and weakfish are showing a modest uptick, with Higbee's Bait and Tackle finding them mixed into Delaware Bay drifts and Big Dave's Tackle noting a targeted bite starting on soft plastics near the lighthouses.
New to these readings? What water temp, tide, and moon phase mean for fishing →
What's biting
What's next
Water is holding at 67.6°F off Sandy Hook and 64.4°F off Cape May, still mild for late September, but the northeast winds behind this week's nor'easter should knock both numbers down and push more striped bass into the surf and back bays. Pier 47 Marina's night bite around the Wildwoods lighted docks is worth watching as bait keeps pushing out of the back bays; expect it to build through the weekend as mullet and peanut bunker schools move. Golden Eagle out of Northern New Jersey expects the bluefish-and-bait pattern to hold into October if the weather cooperates, and with fluke now closed for the year, surf effort should shift toward blues, tautog, and the tail end of the albie run.
Plan around the morning tide: low near 1 AM and high around 7 AM at Sandy Hook, with Cape May running roughly an hour behind. The full moon this week means bigger tidal swings, worth timing around the higher water for both the striper night bite and the tautog bite on the jetties.
Context
This is the typical late-September turn for the Jersey Shore: fluke season closing on schedule while bluefish, tautog, and early striped bass activity build together as water eases off its summer highs. False albacore and bonito working the surf is a normal feature of this stretch of the fall run. Tautog moving onto structure with the first cool nights is right on schedule. The bigger striper push that anglers watch for through October is still building, consistent with a typical early-fall pattern for this part of the coast.
Synthesized from real-time NOAA buoy data, USGS stream gauges, and current reports across regional fishing blogs, captain updates, and angler forums. Check local regulations before keeping fish. Never trust a single source for a trip decision.
EVERY SATURDAY MORNING
Weekly fishing intelligence
Nationwide conditions, what's biting, and honest gear deals. One email, no noise.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.