Best Fly Reels for Trout Fishing: From Budget to Premium
Fly reels occupy an interesting space in gear discussions — for freshwater trout fishing, the reel is primarily a line storage device. Trout rarely make screaming runs that test a drag system. The reel holds your line, balances your rod, and provides a smooth drag for the occasional larger fish. It doesn't need to be a $400 machined aerospace precision instrument for CT trout fishing. That said, cheap fly reels with inconsistent drags, rough retrieves, and poor arbor design create problems. Here's where value and quality intersect for CT-specific trout fishing.
Some links in our gear reviews may be affiliate links — we always disclose when they are. We never accept payment for favorable coverage. If something isn't worth your money, we'll say so.
Orvis Clearwater Large Arbor
Best value fly reel for CT trout fishingThe Orvis Clearwater reel is what I'd put on the starter fly outfit — it's matched in quality to the Orvis Encounter rod (also reviewed here), performs reliably for CT trout and bass, and the Orvis warranty backstops any issues. For anglers fishing the Farmington River for 12-18 inch browns, this reel's drag system handles everything you'll encounter.
Lamson Liquid
Best mid-range fly reel — the upgrade worth makingThe Lamson Liquid is the reel I'd put on my rod if I were starting fresh today. The sealed conical drag is genuinely exceptional — smooth from the first click of drag engagement, consistent under pressure. For anyone fishing seriously on CT rivers 10+ days per year, the jump from the Clearwater to the Liquid is one of the most satisfying gear upgrades available at this price point.
Redington Behemoth
Best budget machined fly reelThe Behemoth hits the price point between the Clearwater and Lamson perfectly. Die-cast aluminum construction is notably more durable than the Orvis Clearwater's injection-molded plastic, and the cork drag is smooth enough for the fish you'll encounter in CT. For an angler stepping up from a beginner fly outfit, this is a solid reel choice.
Buying Guide
**Large Arbor vs. Standard Arbor**
Large arbor fly reels have a larger diameter core, which means: - Faster line retrieve per revolution (important in fast CT current where you quickly need to take in slack) - Less line coiling (more memory issues come from tight coils on small arbors) - Smoother drag pressure (larger drag surface)
Standard arbor reels are heavier for the same capacity and retrieve line slower. Large arbor is now the standard design and worth the minor price premium.
**Matching Reel Weight to Rod**
A fly reel that's too heavy makes the rod feel front-heavy and fatiguing. A reel too light doesn't balance the rod properly. Most manufacturers list compatible rod weights. For a 9-foot 5-weight rod, a reel sized for 5-6 weight is standard. Physically hold the assembled rod with the reel attached — it should feel balanced at the grip when you hold it.
**Drag Systems for CT Trout**
For freshwater trout under 20 inches (which describes the vast majority of CT Farmington River fish), virtually any functioning drag system works. The drag matters more when targeting larger fish — wild browns in 20-inch-plus range, bass on a 7-weight, or any saltwater species. If you plan to fish only CT trout, don't over-invest in drag quality. If you plan to use the same reel for CT stripers on a heavier rod, upgrade to a quality sealed drag.
**Backing and Line Loading**
Fly reels hold backing (typically 20-30 lb dacron), fly line (90 feet), and leader (9-12 feet). Most freshwater trout reels hold 30 yards of backing under a 5-weight floating line — adequate for CT trout that rarely run more than 20 yards. Load the backing first (attach to spool with an arbor knot), then attach the fly line to the backing with a loop-to-loop connection or nail knot.
Rods, reels, flies, and everything for CT fly fishing — subscribe to Hooked Fisherman.
Sign Up — Free