The $89 Reel That Handles Every CT Trout Except the Farmington's Wild Browns
For most CT trout anglers, the Redington Behemoth or a comparable mid-range disc drag reel is the sweet spot — quality drag, large arbor for quick line recovery, and a price that doesn't make anglers afraid to use it. Abel and Ross reels are exceptional but require a serious commitment to the sport to justify.
| Product | Verdict | Approx. price | Links |
|---|---|---|---|
| Redington Behemoth 5/6 | Best value fly reel — powerful cork drag for the price, aggressive large arbor, and Redington's quality control at a beginner-accessible price | $89 | Check price |
| Orvis Clearwater Large Arbor Reel | Best mid-range upgrade — Orvis engineering, lifetime warranty, and a reel commonly recommended by Farmington River guides as an all-around trout tool | $129 | Check price |
A Redington Behemoth runs $89. An Abel Vaya runs roughly $600. On most Connecticut trout water, that gap buys almost nothing — the average stocked fish runs under 18 inches and the fight rarely clears 30 seconds, so the reel mostly stores line rather than fighting fish. Anglers who fish the Farmington River's Trout Management Area tell a different story: a wild brown in the 20-inch class makes a real run, and a cheap spring-and-pawl drag can lose that fish on the first surge. Below is where the price actually buys performance, and where it's just weight and cosmetics.
Some links are affiliate links — we disclose them and earn a small commission at no cost to you. We never accept payment for favorable coverage. If something isn't worth your money, we say so.
Redington Behemoth 5/6
The Redington Behemoth wins its price tier with a cork drag system at $89, while most reels in this range rely on spring-and-pawl drags that offer minimal stopping power. On Farmington River TMA water, where a wild brown occasionally makes a genuine run, that drag difference is often the reason a fish stays hooked. The large arbor picks up slack quickly when a fish runs toward the angler. Users upgrading from basic combo reels typically notice the jump immediately.
Orvis Clearwater Large Arbor Reel
The Orvis Clearwater is a common step-up recommendation for anglers moving past beginner setups. The lifetime warranty is real value: a drag or frame issue gets repaired or replaced through Orvis directly. Guides on the Farmington and Housatonic report the disc drag stays smooth in cold spring water, a season when some cheaper drags stiffen or stick. Many anglers keep this reel in rotation for a decade or more before replacing it.
Buying guide
**Does the Fly Reel Actually Matter for Trout?**
For most trout fishing — fish under 20 inches, quick fights, mostly hand-lining fish in — the reel functions as a line holder. The drag rarely engages long enough during the fight to make a practical difference between an $89 reel and a $300 reel. A 14-inch stocked rainbow is not typically lost because a drag isn't perfectly linear.
Where reel quality does matter, based on public DEEP data and angler reports: - Large wild fish: 18+ inch Farmington River TMA browns, Housatonic River TMA rainbows, or an occasional stray broodstock salmon on the Shetucket - False albacore or stripers on a fly rod — species that test any drag system regardless of species targeted - Long-term durability — cheap drags commonly fail after a few seasons of hard use; quality drags often last decades - Cold-weather performance — some drags stiffen in 35-degree water in early spring; better disc drags don't
CT DEEP's Trout Management Areas — the Farmington River, the Housatonic River, and the Salmon River among them — restrict some sections to artificial lures and flies, and several stretches see catch-and-release pressure across an entire season. Anglers active in Connecticut fly-fishing forums describe a consistent pattern as of the 2025 season: those who moved from spring-and-pawl to disc-drag reels reported fewer break-offs specifically on TMA browns, not on ordinary stocked fish downstream of those sections.
**Arbor Size: Standard vs. Large**
Standard arbor uses the traditional spool diameter. It holds plenty of line and backing, but each revolution retrieves only a small amount of line. It has a classic feel that some anglers prefer.
Large arbor uses a wider spool diameter, so each revolution retrieves more line and slack gets picked up faster. That matters most when a fish runs toward the angler. It's the dominant design in modern fly reels and is generally worth the small extra weight.
**Drag System Types**
Spring-and-pawl is the traditional click drag, providing minimal tension. It's fine for small fish in small streams but isn't well suited to anything that runs hard.
Disc drag is the modern standard for quality reels. A disc of composite material — cork is traditional and performs well — presses against the spool to create adjustable tension. It's smooth, powerful, and consistent, and it's the type worth prioritizing in any reel fished hard on TMA water.
**Retrieve: Right or Left Hand?**
Fly fishers traditionally cast with their dominant hand and retrieve with the non-dominant hand, the opposite of spinning tackle. A right-handed caster typically reels with their left hand as a result. Most quality fly reels convert between retrieve sides with a screwdriver or no tool at all. Decide on retrieve side before buying a fixed model, since converting a fixed-retrieve reel later usually isn't possible.
EVERY SATURDAY MORNING
Weekly fishing intelligence
Nationwide conditions, what's biting, and honest gear deals. One email, no noise.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.