Best Fly Reels for Trout Fishing: What to Buy at Every Budget
Fly fishing gatekeepers will insist you need a $400 reel to properly fish a 5-weight. This is mostly wrong. For trout fishing in Connecticut — where the average fish is under 18 inches and the fight rarely exceeds 30 seconds — the reel primarily serves as a line storage device. That said, a quality reel with a reliable drag does matter when you hook a 22-inch wild brown on the Farmington's catch-and-release section, and good reels cast line more smoothly and last decades. Here's the honest breakdown.
Some links in our gear reviews may be affiliate links — we always disclose when they are. We never accept payment for favorable coverage. If something isn't worth your money, we'll say so.
Redington Behemoth 5/6
Best value fly reel — powerful cork drag for the price, aggressive large arbor, and Redington's quality control at a beginner-accessible priceThe Redington Behemoth wins its price tier by offering a smooth cork drag system at the $89 price point — most reels at this price use spring-and-pawl drags that provide minimal stopping power. For CT trout fishing where fish occasionally run, the Behemoth's drag prevents break-offs better than a pawl system. The large arbor means the spool picks up line quickly when a fish runs toward you. A genuine step up from basic combo reels.
Orvis Clearwater Large Arbor Reel
Best mid-range upgrade — Orvis engineering, lifetime warranty, and the reel most Farmington River guides recommend as an all-around trout toolThe Orvis Clearwater Reel is the standard recommendation for anglers stepping up from beginner setups. The lifetime warranty from Orvis is genuine value — if anything goes wrong with the drag or frame, Orvis will repair or replace it. The disc drag is reliable and smooth in cold CT spring water, where some cheaper drags become sticky. A reel you'll use for 10+ years.
Abel TR 5/6
Best premium fly reel — hand-machined in Camarillo, CA, with the most precise drag feel available in any trout reel. A statement piece that performs as well as it looks.The Abel TR is what you buy when you've decided fly fishing is a lifetime pursuit and you want equipment that will outlast you. The drag system is in a different class from production reels — it's designed to perform consistently whether the spool is full or nearly empty, which matters when a fish is running and drag tension changes as spool diameter decreases. For perspective: the drag on an Abel TR handles 20+ pound fish. You'll probably never hook a 20-pound fish on a 5-weight in Connecticut. Buy it because it's exceptional craftsmanship, not because you need it.
Buying Guide
**Does the Fly Reel Actually Matter for Trout?**
For most trout fishing (fish under 20 inches, quick fights, mostly hand-lining fish in), the reel is a line holder. The drag rarely engages for enough of the fight to make a practical difference between a $89 reel and a $300 reel. You are not going to lose a 14-inch stocked rainbow because your drag isn't linear.
Where reel quality matters: - Large wild fish (18+ inch Farmington brown trout, early-season steelhead if you travel) - False albacore or stripers on a fly rod — these fish will test any drag system - Long-term durability (cheap drags fail after seasons of use; quality drags last decades) - Cold weather performance (some drags stiffen in 35-degree water, the best don't)
**Arbor Size: Standard vs. Large**
Standard arbor: The traditional spool diameter. Holds plenty of line and backing, but each revolution retrieves a small amount of line. Feels classic.
Large arbor: Wider spool diameter means each revolution retrieves more line — you pick up slack much faster. Better for fishing situations where fish run toward you. The dominant design in modern fly reels and worth the slight additional weight.
**Drag System Types**
Spring-and-pawl: Traditional click drag that provides minimal tension. Fine for small fish in small streams. Not appropriate for anything that runs.
Disc drag: The modern standard for quality reels. A disc of composite material (cork is traditional and excellent) presses against the spool to create adjustable tension. Smooth, powerful, consistent. What to look for in any reel you plan to fish hard.
**Retrieve: Right or Left Hand?**
Fly fishers traditionally cast with their dominant hand and retrieve with the non-dominant hand (the opposite of spinning tackle). So a right-handed caster typically reels with their left hand. Most quality fly reels are convertible (switch with a screwdriver or tool-free). Decide before buying a fixed-retrieve model.
From beginner setups to premium tools — honest fly fishing gear reviews for Connecticut anglers. Subscribe to Hooked Fisherman.
Sign Up — Free