Fishing with Eels for Striped Bass: The Most Effective Trophy Striper Bait
Ask any veteran Connecticut striper angler what bait consistently produces the largest fish, and the answer is almost always eels. American eels move naturally through the water in a way that massive stripers find irresistible, and the largest fish are regularly caught on eels during fall migrations. This is the guide to doing it right.
Why Eels Work So Well for Stripers
American eels are a natural prey item that large stripers hunt actively:
Natural prey: Eels are a primary forage fish for large stripers along the Atlantic coast. Stripers hunt eels in rocky habitats, tidal rivers, and estuary edges — exactly the habitat anglers target.
Movement: Live eels move with a sinusoidal slithering motion that triggers predatory response in stripers. The presentation is difficult to resist even for large, cautious fish.
Nocturnal activity: Eels are primarily nocturnal, as are large stripers. Both are active at the same time, in the same places. A live eel in the right location at night is incredibly effective.
Size profile: A 10-15 inch eel matches the size of forage that large stripers (30+ inches) actively target. Small stripers are harder to hook on eels — the bait size self-selects for larger fish.
Scent: The mucous slime coating of eels releases strong chemical attractors. In moving current, the scent trail is powerful.
Getting and Storing Eels
Obtaining and keeping eels alive requires some preparation:
Where to buy: Most bait shops on the CT coast carry live eels seasonally (spring-fall). Call ahead — not all shops stock them daily. Some tackle shops on the Housatonic and CT River mouths have them most reliably.
Storage at home: Eels survive in a cooler with a thin layer of water and ice. They're hardy — a half-inch of ice-cold water keeps them alive for days in a refrigerator. Do NOT submerge eels — they can drown in too much water.
On the water: Bring a cooler with a tight lid. Eels are escape artists — they'll find any gap in a standard bait bucket. A cooler with a locked lid prevents the frustrating experience of arriving at your spot to find the eel escaped in your car.
Handling: Use a dry rag or sand on your hands to grip eels. The slime makes them nearly impossible to hold with bare wet hands. Grip firmly near the head.
Rigging Live Eels
Eel rigging is simple but important:
Basic hook rig: Size 6/0-8/0 live bait or circle hook. Hook through the lower jaw and out the upper jaw (lip hook) — this leaves the eel swimming freely and is the most common method.
Alternate: Hook through the eye socket area. The eel lives longer and the hook position is strong. Used for casting where the presentation requires the hook to stay in place during the cast impact.
No weight (preferred): Rigging with no sinker allows the eel to swim naturally and descend to the bottom on its own. The natural movement is the attraction — weight interferes.
Light fluorocarbon leader: 30-40 lb fluorocarbon leader, 18-24 inches. No wire — large stripers can be leader-shy on calm nights.
Drop-back technique: When a striper takes the eel, drop the rod tip and give slack line for 3-5 seconds before setting the hook. Stripers grab eels and then turn them headfirst before swallowing — setting too early pulls the hook from a sideways fish.
Where and When to Fish Eels
Location and timing are critical for eel fishing success:
Rocky shoreline at night: The best eel fishing is from rocky points, jetties, and boulder-strewn shorelines at night. Cast the eel out, let it sink to bottom, and slowly retrieve with long sweeps of the rod.
Bridge shadow lines: The edge of light/dark shadow under a bridge is a prime eel location. Cast the eel into the shadow and let it work.
Tidal rips: Current rips near structure concentrate both bait and stripers. An eel swimming through a rip often gets hit immediately.
Tide timing: The 3 hours of moving current around high tide is the most productive window. Moving current activates both eels and the stripers hunting them.
Fall season: September through November is prime eel season. The stripers are staging for migration and feeding aggressively. The biggest fish of the year come from fall eel sessions.
Technique: Working the Eel
An eel requires active presentation to be maximally effective:
Cast and swim: Cast to rocky structure, let the eel sink, then slowly swim it back along bottom. Long sweeping retrieves (3-4 foot rod sweeps) with pauses produce most strikes.
Boat drifting: From a boat in a tidal rip, drop the eel to the bottom and drift through the rip at current speed. Maintain contact with the bottom and feel for takes.
Following eels: Large stripers sometimes follow eels for long distances before striking. Don't rush the retrieve — a slow, deliberate presentation allows following fish to commit.
Strikes: Eel strikes range from a subtle weight increase to a violent line rip. React to all anomalies. When in doubt — drop back, feel, set.
Hooking on circle hooks: If using circle hooks (recommended for larger fish), let the fish run without striking. Reel tight and the circle hook seats in the corner of the mouth automatically.
Eels, chunks, plugs, and fly — Connecticut's striper fishery rewards specialists. Subscribe to Hooked Fisherman for technique deep-dives and in-season reports.
Sign Up — Free